Anglican Commemoration
Bishop in South India & Evangelist
January 2 · d. 1945
also known as Samuel Azariah, V.S. Azariah
Vedanayagam Samuel Azariah (1874 to 1945) was the first Indian consecrated a bishop of the Anglican Communion, and for thirty-three years the Bishop of Dornakal in Telugu-speaking South India. Born in Tamil country to a pastor's family, he built Indian-funded missionary societies, led the diocese through a mass movement of outcaste communities into the Church, and spent two decades arguing and negotiating for the union that became the Church of South India in 1947.
Vedanayagam Samuel Azariah was born in 1874 in the village of Vellalanvilai, in the Tirunelveli country of Tamil South India, and he was not the first Christian in his house. His father, Thomas, had been converted in 1839 at a mission school and had gone on to serve as a pastor there. His mother, Ellen, had waited thirteen years between her daughter's birth and his, and when he came she dedicated him as Hannah dedicated Samuel, and gave him the prophet's name. So the boy grew up inside a faith already two generations deep, and what he would do with his life was not a break with his people but a continuation of it.
At Madras Christian College he read mathematics, fell ill before the final examination, and never took the degree. He came away with something else instead. The principal, Dr. William Miller, gave him the name Azariah, and it is the name by which the whole world came to know him.
He went to work for the YMCA, the first Indian secretary in the South, and travelled. In 1896 he met the American student-movement leader John R. Mott, who noted his enthusiasm and remembered it. In 1903 he helped found the Indian Missionary Society of Tirunelveli, and on Christmas Day of 1905, with his college friend K. T. Paul and fifteen others, the National Missionary Society of India: societies run by Indians and paid for by Indians, at a time when almost nobody thought Indians could do either.
Then came Edinburgh. In June 1910 the whole Western missionary establishment gathered for the World Missionary Conference, and on a Monday evening in the Assembly Hall a young Indian clergyman rose to speak on the problem of co-operation between foreign and native workers. Consider what he was standing in front of: the men who ran the mission societies, who paid the salaries, who decided which Indians were fit for which offices. He began by saying, courteously and plainly, that India would need Western missionaries for years to come. And then he told them what all their giving had not yet given. "You have given your goods to feed the poor. You have given your bodies to be burned. We also ask for love. Give us FRIENDS!" The capital letters are in the printed record. Everyone in that hall knew the passage from Saint Paul he was standing on, and knew what Paul says such gifts amount to without love. In the same hall that week sat an American bishop, Charles Henry Brent, who went away convinced the conference had ducked the harder question of Christian unity altogether, and among the young stewards was a future Archbishop of Canterbury.
In 1909 he had been ordained; he began learning Telugu, a language not his own, and went to the Dornakal district of Hyderabad State. On 29 December 1912, in St Paul's Cathedral, Calcutta, with the Metropolitan of India presiding and ten other bishops assisting, he was consecrated the first Bishop of Dornakal: a diocesan bishop, not an assistant, and the first Indian ever consecrated a bishop of the Anglican Communion. Isabel Whitehead, the wife of his mentor Bishop Henry Whitehead, urged him to wear a turban for the occasion; to her it was the very emblem of a dignified Orient. To Azariah it looked like either the cloth a labourer wraps against the sun or the headgear of princes and Brahmans, and he wore a plain cassock instead.
What followed was thirty-three years of unglamorous building in a country whose language he had learned as a grown man. In 1924 the diocese had eight British priests and fifty-three Indian clergy; by 1935 it had two hundred and fifty ordained Indian clergy, more than two thousand village teachers, clinics, cooperatives and printing presses. The Anglican population of the diocese rose from 56,681 in 1912 to 225,080 in 1941, most of them from the communities then called the depressed classes, for whom baptism was also an exit from a stigma the world had fixed on them. Azariah watched them closely and without condescension. When converts of their own accord gave up beef to lower the prejudice of caste neighbours against the faith, he wrote that he was very much amused, and that the campaign's coming entirely from them was among the most encouraging facts he knew. He reminded his diocese that the religion of Christ refuses to be confined to any one race, class, or caste, and that if it ever becomes petrified and static, it is dead.
It cost him. Gandhi opposed the mass conversions, holding them exploitative and, at a moment when British constitutional reform was tying political representation to religious community, a threat to keeping the untouchables inside a Hinduism he meant to reform from within. This was not a foreign missionary against an Indian patriot. It was two Indians disagreeing about what the liberation of the oppressed actually required, reform from inside or a real way out, and Azariah, who had spent his whole life fighting for Indian hands on Indian church work, took the harder side of a popular argument. He saw further than the quarrel. He warned of a time coming when nationalism would be identified with loyalty to the ancient religion of the land, and would look with suspicion on any religion not supposed to belong to the soil.
He built his cathedral at Dornakal with Indian money only, no missionary funds, its frontage like a temple's and its towers like minarets, and it was consecrated on the Epiphany, in his own lifetime. And all through those years he kept working at the thing he had asked for at Edinburgh. At Lausanne in 1927 he told the world conference on Faith and Order, with Brent presiding in that room, that the divisions of Christendom might be a source of weakness in Christian countries, but that in non-Christian lands they were a sin and a scandal. He had organised the Tranquebar Conference in 1919, where thirty-three church leaders, thirty-one of them Indian, called for one visible Church in South India; he chaired the negotiations that followed for the rest of his life.
He died at Dornakal on the first day of 1945, aged seventy, and was buried in the compound of the cathedral he had built. Two and a half years later the Church of South India was inaugurated, Anglicans and Congregationalists and Presbyterians and Methodists in one body, the first union of its kind since the Reformation. He did not live to see it. But the thing he had asked a hall full of strangers for in 1910, and had never stopped asking for, was granted after all.
You are probably not being asked to give your goods to feed the poor this week, and almost certainly not your body to be burned. Azariah stood before people who had done both, and told them that what he wanted from them was friendship: to be received as an equal, to study and worship and learn beside them rather than under them. It is the harder gift, because it costs status rather than money, and he asked for it out loud in a room that had every reason not to grant it. Where in your own life are you giving generously to people you have not yet consented to stand level with?
The record for Azariah is unusually good for a saint, because he lived in the age of printing presses and conference stenographers. Two of his addresses survive verbatim in the official proceedings of the conferences that heard them: the Edinburgh address of 20 June 1910 in the World Missionary Conference's own ninth volume, published that same year, and the Lausanne address of 14 August 1927 in the proceedings edited by H. N. Bate. A near-contemporary history, Eyre Chatterton's A History of the Church of England in India (1924), written by a bishop then serving in India, supplies the consecration date and venue, the eleven participating bishops, and a 1920 Synod resolution placing the CMS and SPG districts of Telugu country under his jurisdiction. The modern standard is Susan Billington Harper's In the Shadow of the Mahatma (2000), grown out of a 1991 Oxford doctorate and built on diocesan records and family correspondence not previously studied; his own papers were largely lost or destroyed after his death, and what survives is scattered across the CMS archives at Birmingham, the USPG archives at Oxford, Lambeth Palace Library, Bishop's College Calcutta, and Palayamkottai.
Several things remain unsettled, and are better named than smoothed over. The consecration of the Dornakal cathedral is given as 1936 by some sources and 1939 by others; this page names the feast day, Epiphany, and no year. The first publication of his most widely translated book, Christian Giving, is variously reported as 1939, 1940 and 1955, and 1955 cannot be a first edition since it follows his death by ten years. The sources say he was ordained in 1909 but do not agree on, or in most cases specify, whether that was to the diaconate or the priesthood. One frequently cited academic reference gives his YMCA secretaryship as beginning in 1885, which is impossible against an 1874 birth; 1895 is the year the other sources give and the one arithmetic allows.
The Gandhi controversy is real and well documented in outline, but thinly in its particulars. The claim that Gandhi once called Azariah postcolonial India's Enemy Number One is a reported claim carried by modern reference sources citing a chapter of Harper's biography, and no primary occasion, date or publication for the remark has been traced here. Three of the quotations on this page come by way of Harper's magazine article, which prints them under her own byline without naming the underlying documents. The manifesto of the 1919 Tranquebar Conference, often quoted as though it were his, is a collective declaration signed by thirty-three men, and is not quoted here as his words.
Azariah's is a modern commemoration rather than an ancient devotion. There is no shrine, no pilgrimage, no relics, no canonisation apparatus of any kind; what there is instead is a calendar entry, and the calendars agree. The Church of England's Common Worship, the Episcopal Church, and the Anglican Church in North America's Book of Common Prayer 2019 all keep him on 2 January, the last of these wording it "Vedanayagam Samuel Azariah, Bishop in South India, Evangelist, 1945." The Episcopal collect asks that those who celebrate him may be strengthened by his witness to God's love without concern for class or caste.
The material memory of him is largely institutional. The Cathedral Church of the Most Glorious Epiphany at Dornakal is still the seat of the bishop and a working parish church, and holds his grave. Bishop Azariah College at Dornakal continues to teach Christian and non-Christian students alike. And in 1951, for the SPG's 250th anniversary, four windows were set in the society's chapel in London depicting the first four indigenous bishops of the Anglican Communion: Samuel Ajayi Crowther of the Niger, Azariah of India, Tsae Seng Sing of China, and Joseph Sakunoshin Motoda of Japan. A second window at St Mark's, Bromley, installed in 1956, sets him beside Crowther and the martyr John Coleridge Patteson.
The two addresses quoted here survive in the official printed proceedings of the conferences that heard them. The Edinburgh peroration ("You have given your goods to feed the poor... Give us FRIENDS!") is Address III, "The Problem of Co-operation between Foreign and Native Workers," delivered in the Assembly Hall on 20 June 1910, in World Missionary Conference, 1910, vol. IX, The History and Records of the Conference (Oliphant, Anderson & Ferrier / Fleming H. Revell, 1910), pp. 306 to 315, the quoted passage at p. 315, including its capitalised FRIENDS. The Lausanne line on divisions as "a sin and a scandal" is from his address of 14 August 1927, in Faith and Order: Proceedings of the World Conference, Lausanne, August 3-21, 1927, ed. H. N. Bate (New York: George H. Doran, 1927), pp. 491 to 495, the passage at p. 495. Both volumes are public domain and freely readable at the Internet Archive (`historyrecordsof00worliala` and `wccfops1.066`).
Three shorter quotations, on the anti-beef campaign, on a religion petrified and static, and on nationalism and the religion of the soil, are reported by Susan Billington Harper in "Hope for Outcastes," Christian History (Christianity Today), issue 87, which also supplies the 1912 and 1941 diocesan population figures and the turban episode; the article names no underlying document for any of them. Harper's full biography is In the Shadow of the Mahatma: Bishop V. S. Azariah and the Travails of Christianity in British India (Grand Rapids and Cambridge: Eerdmans / Curzon, 2000), 462 pp., ISBN 0-8028-3874-X, the standard modern study. The earliest full life is Carol Graham, Azariah of Dornakal (London: SCM Press, 1946). For the consecration and the early diocese, Eyre Chatterton, A History of the Church of England in India (1924), ch. XXV, is available at anglicanhistory.org. His own book with Bishop Henry Whitehead, Christ in the Indian Villages (SCM Press, 1930), is scanned at the Internet Archive. The reference portrait is a bromide print by the Madras studio Wiele & Klein, c. 1912, National Portrait Gallery, London, NPG x8841.
Almighty and everlasting God, you called your servant Vedanayagam Samuel Azariah to preach the Gospel to the people of India: Raise up in this and every land evangelists and heralds of your kingdom, that your Church may proclaim the unsearchable riches of our Savior Jesus Christ; who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever. Amen.
Readings for a Missionary
Isaiah 49:1–7Psalm 98Romans 10:11–18Luke 5:1–11